Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

A challenging project for me – but coming along quite nicely

Featured Replies

I just posted this at another forum that I frequent and decided I'd post it here, since I don't see a lot of projects get posted in this section. I love talking tools and techniques, but I like seeing what my fellow neanders are building even more. So here's what I have to share - feedback is welcome...

A challenging project for me – but coming along quite nicely

post-4431-0-79972200-1316713673_thumb.jp

Hey folks,

I started this project about 6 months ago (but got distracted mid way through with rehabbing some saws). I was going to wait to post this until it was complete, but just got to a point where it’s really starting to come together so I thought I’d share the progress. I am building a jewelry chest of drawers for my mother and will give it to her this Xmas as a present. My grandfather has built several similar chests for my aunts but he’s doing less woodworking these days, so since my mom never got one from him, she asked if I could build one for her. The chest is my own design - it combines a fairly standard plan that my grandfather used for his chests, with a number of features from traditional Pennsylvania spice boxes.

The chest is about 14”x14”x7.5”. A picture with my cat (Totem) is included to give some scale of the size.

post-4431-0-29089300-1316713686_thumb.jp

The primary wood came from a lovely piece of streaky cherry I got from my local lumber dealer. The coves on the molding were shaped on a router, but everything else has been done without electrons. I work this way 1) because it’s fun and 2) because I lack a dedicated shop space so working by hand on my workbench inside the house is much easier and more pleasant than setting up my portable power tools on the back patio. I’m sure I will always do a lot of handwork, but having done a number of hand tool only projects at this point, I know that when I have a more dedicated space I will very quickly want to acquire a thickness planer and a huge bandsaw.

The interior dividers/partitions are poplar with about an inch of cherry trim glued to the show surfaces. They sit in stopped dados, which were made by first knocking out the waste at the stopped end with a chisel, then kerfing the sides with a backsaw, and finally cleaned out with my router plane.

post-4431-0-27855900-1316713621_thumb.jp post-4431-0-11359900-1316713613_thumb.jp

After cutting all the interior dados, rabbets, grooves, the carcass top/bottom and sides were dovetailed together, and the interior components were slid in from the back.

post-4431-0-62213300-1316713626_thumb.jp

I then made the soft maple frame and panel back, which is perhaps the coolest part since its removable and reveals a hidden compartment, that sits behind a false back in the top row of drawers. (got this idea from Steve Latta’s PA spice box)

post-4431-0-72118700-1316713651_thumb.jp post-4431-0-17020100-1316713666_thumb.jp

I then shaped and fit the molding which turned out to be a major PITA. I repeatedly shot them to short in getting the miters to fit right, and then kept having to plane the molding backs to make the moldings “grow”. I was very obsessive about getting the miters tight, and in the end I got a really nice fit, which made me VERY happy after struggling so much to get them right – slightly imperfect joinery I can live with, but a gappy miter looks really bad.

post-4431-0-87865600-1316713641_thumb.jp post-4431-0-41365000-1316713631_thumb.jp

So what’s next? I will be adding some bracket feet made from the same piece of cherry – the photo below shows the template I plan to use (and yes, I realize the grain on the template is running in the wrong direction). Then it’s just a matter of making the nine drawers that will go into the case. Below is a picture of some lightly spalted QS sycamore I will be using for the drawer fronts. I spent a lot of time debating whether or not to use a different species for the drawers, since contrasting wood is so very easy to do poorly. I was originally going to use birdeye maple, but decided that the contrast would be to heavy and the figure too busy. I think the tan/orange undertones of the sycamore, and the light spalting will pair much nicer with the streaks and tones of the cherry case – hopefully you agree.

post-4431-0-20186500-1316713693_thumb.jp post-4431-0-88284300-1316713698_thumb.jp

I’m still deciding what I will use as a finish. The interior is prefinished with some Bullseye sealcoat. I had originally planned on using Tried and True original which has become my standby, but now am thinking that amber shellac may add so nice warmth to the piece.

This is definitely is the most challenging piece I’ve done, and even though it’s taking a long time and there have been some hiccups, I am really happy with how it’s turning out.

So thanks for letting me show off my work, I hope you enjoyed it!

Neat project. Two comments:

I had never heard the trick of planing the back of molding to make it "grow". (Not that I have ever needed such a trick myself. :).)

It's not hard to see that second picture as a regular-sized chest of drawers next to a really big cat.

-- Russ

  • Author

Neat project. Two comments:

I had never heard the trick of planing the back of molding to make it "grow". (Not that I have ever needed such a trick myself. :).)

It's not hard to see that second picture as a regular-sized chest of drawers next to a really big cat.

-- Russ

Thanks Russ! The making moldings grow trick I think I got out of FWW. Since the molding is mitered, planing off some of the back brings you up farther into the longer part of the miter and effectively lengthens the glue surface. It saved me from having to recut the moldings, which is good because I didn't have any extra lumber to spare, given that I was trying to make the whole thing from one board so that it would all match.

Regarding the gaint cat, all I can say is... I wish. That would be pretty awesome.

  • 4 weeks later...

I can't wait to see the drawers complete. Love spalted wood! Great project!

  • Author

Thanks folks. I will definitly post when it's finished. I still have 6 drawers to make, and I'm going to redesign the foot template to make the foot a fair bit smaller and more of a subtle detail. I can't wait to get this thing done - I need to put the drawer making into overdrive. It's been a fun project but it's been on my bench for far too long.

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author

6 down, 3 to go....

And, 48 dovetails later (6 drawers x 8 dovetails per drawer [2 tails per joint]), I'm finally nearing the end of this project.

post-4431-0-44115100-1320765752_thumb.jp

Only have the 3 small drawers left for which I got all the stock cut and planed to it's final dminesions this past weekend. Then its just a matter of making (well, after settling on a design for) the feet, inserting drawer bottoms, attaching hardware, finish planing, sanding and finishing.

post-4431-0-82659700-1320765258_thumb.jp

Also, tested out and decided on a finish this past week. Will be sanding up to 600 grit ( to avoid the dreaded blotch), then its a thin coat of BLO, followed by padding on very several thin layers of shellac (think french polish w/o the perfect polish) - rubbed out with some wax and steel wool will give it a nice dull sheen.

I think I'll get it done in time for Xmas (I think I can, I think I can)....

(sorry for the lousy cell phone pictures)

Looks like its coming along nicely, your mom will love it. What was the best part of the project for you and pushed you to be a better woodworker??

Nate

  • Author

Looks like its coming along nicely, your mom will love it. What was the best part of the project for you and pushed you to be a better woodworker??

Nate

Good question, with a lot of potential answers. In many ways, I still a novice woodworker so I tend to learn A LOT of new stuff from every project. I make a point to pick projects that will help me to develop to new skills but the biggest lessons are never what I expect.

I knew the layout and cutting of the interior joinery (all those stopped dados) would be a challenge, and that step certainly did improve my layout abilities/accuracy. Also, trying to get a good piston (okay, pistonish) fit of each drawer into the case has been a definite challenge. And yeah, my DTs and other joinery definitely improved, but the bigger lessons I learn with each project are always more about the subtleties of woodworking.

For instance, in this project I put a lot of time and thought into grain matching/orientation and I really think it will pay off. This is also the first time I've tested a few different finishes in advance, instead of just slapping some BLO or varnish on there, and I already can tell that this will really pay off.

Perhaps most importantly, with each hand tool build I find I get better at understanding how wood works in general - this is subtle and eventually becomes somewhat intuitive, but it can really make the difference between good and great. As I get better working with wood in general, I get less tearout, spelching, chipping, blowout, gouging etc... This mean less cleanup, more accuracy, and ultimately better fitting joints and a cleaner finished product.

I'd say the other major lesson I learned with this project had to do with work flow. That is, identifying when and how to dimension various pieces. For example, I typically take the approach of cutting everything to it's rough sizes before flattening and thickness, since one generally has to remove less wood to bring smaller pieces into flat. However, when it came to doing all those small drawer parts I realized it was easier to take on the power tool mindset of flattening a larger piece and then breaking it down into its components. Flattening all those little pieces just took/would have taken way to long. This is the kind of thing you only learn by actually doing a project.

The more I work with wood the more I realize that learning to cut DTs or any joint for that matter are essentially the basics - you learn how to do them and you move on, sometimes they turn out better than other times, but they don't make or break a piece, and as you get better at working wood in general, you get better at fixing the errors that do occur.

What is it they say? The mark of good woodworker isn't that they make fewer mistakes, it's just that they get better at fixing them (or something like that). Very true....

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.